Back to news

METRO VANCOUVER NEWS

Why B.C. Conservatives promised to bring ‘O Canada’ back to schools

Nov 18, 2026 · Vancouver · Daily Hive Vancouver · Hanna Hett

The B.C. Conservatives say daily school-day anthem singing would help foster pride in the province and country. Teachers’ union president Carole Gordon says schools never stopped singing it, while a UBC education researcher questions the lyrics, a related flag promise and the pledge’s political purpose.

YoLink AI 资料配图

As the B.C. Conservatives are sworn in this week, people are watching for changes the new government may bring. A campaign promise that drew little attention during the election has recently prompted discussion: to “bring back the singing of ‘O Canada’ at the beginning of the school day.” But Carole Gordon, president of the BC Teachers’ Federation (BCTF), says the anthem never left schools. A former music teacher, she says students have sung it throughout her 35 years of teaching. Schools sing it at assemblies, including Remembrance Day assemblies, and she believes most, if not all, schools have done so. She said she has never heard a student, teacher, parent or friend say the anthem should be sung at the start of every school day.

Gordon says the BCTF has been asking the government for more resources, staff, time and investment so students can feel safe, supported and successful. She called daily morning singing “counterproductive,” saying it would take significant time over the school year away from reading, writing and math, subjects the B.C. Conservatives have also discussed. Asked why the party included the pledge, Gordon said that if the suggestion is that schools have lost their pride in Canada, she does not think patriotism needs to be taught: it is part of the surrounding culture, which schools reflect.

Daily Hive Urbanized put the same question to the B.C. Conservatives. In an emailed statement, premier-designate Lorne Doerkson said the party had committed to getting education “back to basics,” including higher academic standards, restoring letter grades and giving parents a clear understanding of their children’s progress. He said bringing back the anthem and proudly flying Canadian and British Columbia flags in schools would also foster pride in the province and country. The party would have more to say after cabinet was sworn in this week.

Justin Fraser, a PhD student in the University of British Columbia’s department of curriculum and pedagogy, sees three reasons for the pledge. He first noted that the anthem was originally used in schools to instil national pride and unity among students. Music can be powerful, he said, because hearing the anthem every day can lead students to internalize its lyrics. But Fraser called the lyrics “incredibly problematic.” Citing “God keep our land glorious and free,” he said they carry many implicit messages: most obviously, an explicit embrace of Christianity and a claim of ownership over the land. He added that Canada is rooted in settler colonialism, including the theft and occupation of Indigenous lands. Hearing the lyrics each day, he said, gradually shapes how students see themselves as Canadian citizens. In his view, the Conservatives are using the anthem to construct what they might regard as a “model Canadian citizen” according to dominant settler Christian values.

Fraser’s second concern is that the anthem pledge appeared in the same sentence as a promise to “proudly fly our Canadian and B.C. flags at every school.” He said virtually all B.C. schools already fly those flags, so at first glance there is no real issue. But he pointed to an Alberta bill passed this year that allows schools to display only Canadian and Alberta flags and bans all other types of flags in the name of neutrality. Fraser called that rationale a “guise” and argued that the policy amounts to an attack on 2SLGBTQIA+ people because it effectively bans Pride flags in schools. The B.C. Conservatives have not said they would ban other flags. Fraser remains concerned, however, given the actions of Alberta’s United Conservative Party and the B.C. Conservatives’ promise to repeal SOGI 123.

His third reason is that making daily anthem singing mandatory “simply fuels the culture wars that help [them] get elected.” Fraser said the anthem debate distracts from chronic underfunding and a lack of resources in B.C. public education. Public schools are grossly underfunded, classrooms overcrowded and short of resources, teachers are repeatedly asked to do more with less, and students’ needs are not being met, he said. He argued that increasing public funding would do more to make public schools accessible and equitable for all students than spending time, energy and resources on bringing the anthem back.

### Other education promises

The B.C. Conservatives’ platform also promised to restore letter grades for Grades 4 to 9, provincial exams and shop classes, and to get education “back to basics” by teaching literacy, mathematics and subject knowledge. The party also said it would further limit phone use in schools, prepare students for life with financial literacy, and give parents clear information about their children’s curriculum and progress.

Gordon said classrooms have changed and teaching cannot simply return to the way it used to be. The BCTF wants to focus on reading, writing and math while preparing students to think critically about the world, which requires a different approach, she said. Learning is not just memorization: students need to understand the world around them, relate to one another, find information and assess whether it is fact, opinion or misinformation so they can make good decisions.

She said a return to basics centred on worksheets, rote learning and memorization is more skills-based. Teaching today puts greater focus on process in writing and editing, problem-solving in math and science, and considering other perspectives in social studies. Gordon also pointed to arts and applied skills, including cooking and trades, saying students need options and preparation for their lives so they can move from school into adulthood successfully.

After the new government is sworn in, Gordon said she looks forward to speaking with the new premier and education minister about what students and teachers need. She said the B.C. Conservatives have not shared their actual education plans with the union; so far, they have been campaign promises.

Read the original source · Daily Hive Vancouver

GOOD THINGS HAPPEN HERE

Download Yo! Vancouver

Scan with your phone camera to discover more local favourites.

Scan to download Yo! Vancouver

Or choose your app store

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play