METRO VANCOUVER NEWS
Person dies on Port Hardy Hospital grounds after emergency response
Island Health says a person died after an emergency response at Port Hardy Hospital on Nov. 19. The circumstances remain unclear, as the health authority reviews the case with B.C. Emergency Health Services amid renewed calls for overnight emergency care in Port Hardy.

For some Port Hardy residents, 5 p.m. is not simply the end of the workday. It is when their local emergency department closes, leaving them worried about what could happen if they need urgent care overnight. A death on the grounds of Port Hardy Hospital has renewed scrutiny of emergency access in the community.
Dr. Alex Nataros, a family physician and founder of the North Island Community Health Centre, said residents live with anxiety and fear each night after the emergency department closes. Some are older, have complex chronic conditions, do not drive and may not want to travel the 43 kilometres to Port McNeill on a difficult, icy road, he said.
Island Health confirmed that a person died following an emergency response on the grounds of Port Hardy Hospital on Nov. 19. The health authority offered condolences to the person’s loved ones and the care teams involved. It said both Island Health care providers and B.C. Emergency Health Services (BCEHS) paramedics responded and provided emergency interventions. Island Health is reviewing the circumstances with BCEHS and said it would be inappropriate to speculate about possible contributing factors while that review is underway. It has not said whether the person sought care before the response or whether anyone was denied medical attention.
Nataros said he does not know the person’s identity or all the circumstances. His account came from a physician colleague involved in resuscitation efforts. According to Nataros, the colleague told him the patient had been outside for an extended period before being brought into the emergency department, well after 5 p.m. He said his colleague performed an intraosseous procedure, which provides access through the bone marrow to give emergency medication when conventional intravenous access cannot be established quickly. Nataros said he understood that the patient died. Island Health has not independently confirmed the timeline or resuscitation details he described.
Nataros said patients have told him personally about their fears during appointments. He recalled three specific patients in his examination room describing anxiety every night after 5 p.m. because of complex chronic diseases and reluctance to leave their community. He said they have repeatedly been failed by basic health-care services for more than four years. Nataros says Port Hardy needs a fully operational, 24-hour emergency department, citing local health-care needs and the challenges faced by people requiring urgent care. He also pointed to addiction and what he called a crisis of deaths of despair from overdoses and suicides.
Nataros said he has advocated for round-the-clock emergency services since fall 2022. He said the emergency department doors have been locked at 5 p.m. since February 2023.
Local physicians propose Port Hardy as permanent overnight ER
A statement from local physicians, provided to CTV News by Nataros, proposes one permanent overnight emergency department for the entire North Island, with Port Hardy as the recommended location. The physicians say staffing shortages have contributed to repeated closures and diversions at both hospitals. Their statement says the burden of overnight emergency coverage has fallen disproportionately on the Port McNeill physician group. They say the strain of closures and diversions harms staff morale, affecting retention and patient-care quality.
The proposal would designate one hospital as the region’s permanent overnight emergency department, supported by a regional physician call group and consolidated resources, including imaging and laboratory services. The physicians say Port Hardy is the strongest location because it has a larger population, higher patient visit volumes and greater acuity in calls to BCEHS. They describe a single overnight ER in Port Hardy as the best long-term solution. While acknowledging that pending renovations will affect short-term planning, they say a permanent regional arrangement is needed.
Nataros said the swearing-in of a new provincial government creates an opportunity to address what he describes as years of inadequate emergency services on the North Island. He is asking new Health Minister Ryan Peterson, Premier Lorne Doerkson and North Island MLA Dr. Anna Kindy, who is also Minister of State for Rural Development, to make restoring 24-hour emergency services in Port Hardy a priority. He said the new cabinet and ministers responsible for health and rural issues offer an opportunity for action, and urged them to work immediately to reopen the ER around the clock. He said the situation has been allowed to continue for too long.
Nataros has been a vocal critic of Island Health’s management of health-care services in the region. He said his Port Hardy Hospital emergency department privileges were terminated in February 2023 after he publicly criticized Island Health leadership and called for the resignation of its then chief medical officer, Ben Williams. He also says he was later banned from Island Health property and warned that the RCMP could be called if he returned. Nataros disputes the circumstances behind the decision, saying a complex patient case was used to damage his professional reputation.
The circumstances of the Nov. 19 death remain unclear. Island Health says it is reviewing the case with BCEHS but has not provided further details about the response or overnight care arrangements for Port Hardy residents. Questions remain about what happens when someone arrives after the emergency department doors are locked, which medical personnel are available overnight and what residents should do if they need emergency assistance. The physicians’ proposal also leaves open whether Island Health will consider a permanent regional overnight emergency department in Port Hardy.
For Nataros, the issue is whether people can access emergency care in their own community. He said residents have spent their lives paying taxes and relying on the health-care system. CTV News says it will continue seeking answers about the death and the future of emergency services in Port Hardy.