METRO VANCOUVER NEWS
Surrey mayor vows to require permits for election signs on private property
Mayor Doug McCallum says a Safe Surrey Coalition-led council would introduce a bylaw in its first year requiring permits for election signs on private property. The proposal follows a separate, court-challenged 2021 sign bylaw that restricted political signs outside election periods.

If Surrey Mayor Doug McCallum has his way, election signs on private property within city limits would require a permit. During October’s municipal election campaign, he also said no 4-by-4-foot or 8-by-4-foot election signs would be allowed anywhere in Surrey. The election gave the Safe Surrey Coalition a commanding majority on council. McCallum said a coalition-led council would introduce a related bylaw in its first year, applying to all candidates and political parties at every level of government.
McCallum said he heard calls to remove election signs at door after door across Surrey. Residents, he said, want candidates to earn votes in person rather than buy them by the square foot, and do not want tax dollars spent cleaning up after campaigns. He said residents do not want plastic signs on every corner for six weeks, followed by leftovers in ditches for six months, and do not believe a sign on a stick tells them who should run the city. McCallum argued a ban would also save money because bylaw officers would no longer have to pull signs out of the ground. He said money and volunteer hours spent on signs should go toward door-knocking and listening to residents, and promised a council he leads would deliver what Surrey residents asked for.
In a separate sign-related matter, opponents condemned changes made during McCallum’s previous term to Surrey’s bylaw governing signs outside election campaigns, calling them an affront to democracy. Then-councillor Linda Annis told council in October 2021 that residents in Canada have every right to express their opinions on their front lawns without fear of repercussions or fines. She said restricting what people can do on their front lawns outside election periods was fundamentally wrong.
Council passed the amendments by a five-to-four vote. McCallum and Safe Surrey Coalition councillors Allison Patton, Laurie Guerra, Mandeep Nagra and Doug Elford voted in favour; Annis, Jack Hundial, Steven Pettigrew and Brenda Locke voted against. The amendments barred anyone from placing, or permitting the placement of, a political sign on public or private property, with exceptions for elections. For federal or provincial by-elections, signs could be placed from the dropping of the writ until 14 days after general voting day. For municipal elections and by-elections, the permitted period ran from the first day of the nomination period until 14 days after general voting day.
In April 2022, six Surrey residents challenged the amendments’ constitutionality in B.C. Supreme Court in Vancouver, seeking an order declaring them “of no force or effect.” After the trial, Justice Nigel Kent ordered the City to revise what he called “poorly drafted” amendments to remove ambiguity. He found that the definition of a political sign extended beyond municipal, provincial and federal elections to political “issues” generally, potentially capturing signs such as “Keep the RCMP in Surrey,” “Save the Whales,” “Stop Logging Old Growth Forests” and “Get Vaccinated.”
Kent concluded that the 2021 amendments created ambiguity that could arguably prohibit political signs on private property except during limited specified periods. Such a restriction, he said, would infringe section 2(b) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which protects the petitioners’ freedom of expression, including political expression.