METRO VANCOUVER NEWS
Downtown Eastside housing workers oppose B.C. non-profit’s facial recognition plan
CUPE Local 5536 says PHS Community Service Society should abandon plans for a facial recognition time clock. CEO Micheal Vonn says the system would replace a manual payroll process plagued by errors, and that employee face photos would be deleted immediately.

The union representing workers at a Downtown Eastside housing non-profit in Vancouver is opposing the employer’s plan to introduce facial recognition for employees. CUPE Local 5536, which represents B.C. harm reduction workers, sent members a letter earlier this month opposing PHS Community Service Society’s proposed “facial recognition-based punch clock.” The letter, obtained by The Canadian Press, says workers would have to scan their faces when arriving at or leaving work and when taking or returning from breaks. The union calls the practice “debasing” and says normalizing artificial intelligence or biometric surveillance in harm reduction would be “reckless and dangerous.” It wants the society to abandon the plan.
Union president Devin Lefebvre, who was recently elected, declined to comment before a meeting with the employer’s leadership on Nov. 19. Society CEO Micheal Vonn says the current manual payroll system needs an urgent upgrade after a series of errors. She says the new touch-free system would use facial recognition, but employee face photos would be deleted immediately. Vonn said in an interview that the technology would be used for authentication and would not involve any kind of biometric surveillance. “It is exactly the kind of technology that many people now use to access their phones and other devices,” she said.
Vonn, a lawyer and former policy director of the BC Civil Liberties Association, said she is “deeply interested” in privacy matters. She said the union’s campaign began before it received a briefing on the new system. Union members have worn buttons opposing facial recognition at work. The union’s letter says implementation “must be stopped” and PHS needs to abandon its plans.
Vonn called the union’s concerns and conclusions premature and overblown, and said the button campaign was inappropriate and based on misinformation. “We are not looking to put this technology in place to catch people out who are five minutes late on their shift or any of those things,” she said. “We have very good and compelling reasons why we want to automate the system.” She said the society wants to introduce it as soon as possible because “sooner would obviously be better for everything relating to the accuracy of the system and ensuring that we pay people appropriately.”
Vonn said people working in supportive housing and harm reduction face deep challenges in “deeply antagonistic times,” as homelessness and the toxic drug crisis persist. “We have very few friends at this juncture in our world,” she said. “Everybody’s in favour of supportive housing as long as it’s on Mars. We have very little social licence, and every day is a freaking battle.”
Vonn said Friday that her meeting with the union covered a range of questions and employee concerns. Lefebvre was unavailable for comment Friday afternoon. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 21, 2026.