Back to news

METRO VANCOUVER NEWS

Judge releases reasons for ruling that mandatory parole restriction is unconstitutional

Nov 13, 2026 · British Columbia · CTV News Vancouver · Ben Miljure

A B.C. Supreme Court judge has explained why she found unconstitutional the rule barring people convicted of multiple murders from seeking earlier parole consideration. The Crown plans to challenge the ruling under Section 1 of the Charter, with a decision expected in early 2027; sentencing is set for February.

YoLink AI 资料配图

A B.C. Supreme Court judge released written reasons Friday for a decision announced last month in a double-murder trial, a ruling that sent shockwaves through the legal community. On Oct. 19, family and friends of Arnold and Joanne De Jong arrived at the Abbotsford Law Courts expecting sentencing for the three men convicted of murdering the senior couple. Instead, the judge ruled that the mandatory 25-year period of parole ineligibility was unconstitutional, delaying sentencing.

The De Jongs’ daughter, Sandra Barthel, told CTV News the decision knocked her family off its feet. She said they had wanted a first-degree murder conviction, but now felt even that no longer held firm, and that the men might as well have pleaded guilty to manslaughter.

Earlier this year, Justice Brenda Brown convicted Abhijeet Singh, Gurkaran Singh and Khushveer Singh Toor of two counts each of first-degree murder. The couple were brutally killed in their Abbotsford home in May 2022.

Under the Criminal Code of Canada, the “faint hope clause” allows some people convicted of murder to apply for parole after 15 years, even when they have a longer period of parole ineligibility. However, Section 745.6(2) excludes people convicted of multiple murders. The defence argued that exclusion violates Section 12 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which protects against cruel and unusual treatment or punishment. The judge agreed.

In her written reasons, Brown said striking down Section 745.6(2) as unconstitutional would not release the offenders. It would give them an opportunity to ask a judge for a hearing before a jury to consider whether they may apply for parole earlier. Even if they clear those two hurdles, the Parole Board of Canada would retain the final decision on whether to grant parole. Brown added that if Singh, Singh and Toor are released in the future, they will remain under some form of control for the rest of their lives.

Barthel told CTV News her family believes in rehabilitation but is also seeking justice. She said she does not believe justice would be served if her parents’ killers are eventually allowed to apply for earlier parole. Her parents were killed while vulnerable and asleep in their home, she said, and the family cannot recover the time they lost with them. Her children will not get their grandparents back. Barthel said the family has been “served a life sentence” without a faint hope clause.

Vancouver criminal lawyer Sarah Leamon is part of Abhijeet Singh’s defence team. She said the defence was pleased to receive the court’s reasons but needed time to review them and consider next steps. She also said the case was at least one step closer to a final conclusion.

The B.C. Prosecution Service said the Crown will challenge the ruling under Section 1 of the Charter, which permits reasonable limits on rights and freedoms. A decision on that challenge is expected in early 2027, and Singh, Singh and Toor are scheduled for a sentencing hearing in February.

Read the original source · CTV News Vancouver

GOOD THINGS HAPPEN HERE

Download Yo! Vancouver

Scan with your phone camera to discover more local favourites.

Scan to download Yo! Vancouver

Or choose your app store

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play