Back to news

METRO VANCOUVER NEWS

Lawyers question whether $58 million can ease the Federal Court’s soaring caseload

Nov 14, 2026 · Canada · Global News Canada · Globalnews Digital

The Federal Court had nearly 31,000 proceedings launched by Sept. 30, including more than 27,000 immigration cases, compared with about 7,600 in all of 2020. Lawyers say the $58-million commitment may not address the pressures driving the backlog.

YoLink AI 资料配图

The recent federal budget included $58 million in additional funding for court administration, but the Federal Court does not yet know how the money will be used to reduce a caseload that has grown rapidly since 2020. Chief Justice Paul Diner told The Canadian Press in an emailed statement Thursday that the court has no further details on how the confirmed funding will be divided among the stated purposes.

The Federal Court hears immigration matters including visa applications, refugee claims, admissibility cases and removals. It also upholds the law in other areas of federal jurisdiction, such as intellectual property, national security and Indigenous rights. The court sought additional resources after proceedings launched by Sept. 30 this year climbed to nearly 31,000, up from about 7,600 throughout 2020. More than 27,000 of the proceedings started this year are immigration cases.

In an August interview with The Canadian Press, Diner said judges and court staff have been working evenings, weekends and vacation days to manage the growing caseload, driven in large part by immigration matters.

The budget says the money is earmarked for the Courts Administration Service, which serves the Federal Court, Federal Court of Appeal, Tax Court of Canada and Court Martial Appeal Court of Canada. The single mention in documents published Nov. 5 says the funding is intended to address the Federal Court’s caseload and help the service comply with the Official Languages Act, clear a translation backlog and modernize court infrastructure. The additional $58 million is set to begin in the 2027-28 fiscal year and continue for four years, averaging $14.5 million annually.

Joannie Fogue, spokesperson for Justice Minister Sean Fraser, said the funding is intended to “strengthen the national courts,” respond to resource challenges and improve workload efficiencies. Its exact allocation remains unknown. In a media statement, Fogue said the government is still working through the commitment’s details and implications and is awaiting further information about how the funding will be distributed.

As the court awaits details, immigration lawyers question whether the additional money from Ottawa will help cases move through the court more efficiently, given the scale of growing demand. Ottawa-based immigration lawyer Jacqueline Bonisteel said any funding increase is positive, but modest compared with the growth in the Federal Court’s immigration caseload. She said $58 million spread over four years will not be enough to cope with the surge, which she described as a 600 per cent increase in immigration cases since 2020. The current number of judges and available resources, she said, cannot handle an increase of that magnitude. Bonisteel said an immigration case can now take “upwards of two years” to get through the court.

Toronto-based immigration lawyer Zeynab Moayyed agreed that the Federal Court’s problems go beyond what $58 million could fix. She cited a shortage of registry staff and said routine paperwork that used to take about a day to process, such as a filing for judicial review, now takes weeks.

Moayyed attributed part of the caseload increase to more people filing mandamus applications to compel the Immigration Department to make decisions after long delays. Both Moayyed and Bonisteel said the quality of the department’s decisions has declined since the federal government adopted artificial intelligence tools and new software to review and process applications more quickly. They said less direct interaction at the department is turning small problems into larger ones and pushing them onto the court’s caseload.

Moayyed said lawyers previously could contact Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada, including program and visa office managers. If there was a mistake, the department would reconsider and reopen the matter; if there was no mistake, the applicant would understand what they had done wrong. She said the introduction of those tools coincided with the shutdown of informal ways to address problems in the system, leading applicants to turn to Federal Court.

Bonisteel said the department could ease the court’s workload by streamlining reconsideration requests before they are sent to court. She said the problems have multiple dimensions and require several kinds of solutions, including addressing systemic issues behind the caseload increase, not only court funding.

The Immigration Department says its artificial intelligence and advanced analytics tools are always subject to human oversight. It says the tools do not make decisions and are intended to help with tasks such as triaging applications, identifying routine cases, generating case summaries and answering client questions through chatbots. The department’s first AI strategy, released earlier this year, says the goal is to use the technology to reduce application backlogs and wait times.

Moayyed said the long delays are causing “a great deal of distress” for people caught in the system. She said her work, in addition to being an immigration lawyer, has become that of a confidante and therapist for clients, listening as they describe having their lives on hold and in limbo until a decision is made.

Read the original source · Global News Canada

GOOD THINGS HAPPEN HERE

Download Yo! Vancouver

Scan with your phone camera to discover more local favourites.

Scan to download Yo! Vancouver

Or choose your app store

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play