Back to news

METRO VANCOUVER NEWS

Judge releases Charter ruling for three Surrey men convicted in Abbotsford double murder

Nov 16, 2026 · Surrey · Surrey Now-Leader

A B.C. Supreme Court judge ruled that a 25-year period before parole applications would be grossly disproportionate for three men convicted of the Abbotsford killings. The Crown plans to challenge the ruling under section 1 of the Charter; sentencing arguments are expected in the new year.

YoLink AI 资料配图

B.C. Supreme Court Justice Brenda Brown, sitting in Abbotsford, ruled Oct. 19 that a life sentence barring parole applications for 25 years would be “grossly disproportionate” for three Surrey men previously convicted of killing Arnold and Joanne De Jong in Abbotsford in 2022. Her reasons were posted online Monday, Nov. 16.

Khushveer Toor, Gurkaran Singh and Abhijeet Singh were each found guilty May 8 of two counts of first-degree murder. The De Jongs were found dead in their home on May 9, 2022. A first-degree murder conviction carries an automatic life sentence with no parole eligibility for 25 years.

Under the “faint-hope clause,” people convicted of one count of first-degree murder have been able to apply after 15 years in prison to reduce their parole ineligibility period. Those convicted of more than one murder have not been able to apply for early release. The three men asked the court to reconsider the law in their case and shorten the wait before they can apply for parole.

At the hearing, Toor’s lawyer argued that since the provisions were enacted in 1996, “society and courts have become much more sophisticated with respect to their understanding of sentencing.” He compared the case with that of Alexandre Bissonnette, who opened fire on worshippers at the Great Mosque of Quebec in January 2017, killing six people. Bissonnette received a life sentence with no parole eligibility for 40 years. The Quebec Court of Appeal overturned that decision in 2020 and set the period at 25 years. The Supreme Court of Canada upheld the appeal court’s decision.

Toor’s lawyer argued it would be “grossly disproportionate” for the three men to receive the same sentence as someone who murdered six people and attempted to kill more. The Crown argued that the De Jong murders were “highly morally blameworthy” and “brutal and callous.” It had told the court: “The murders themselves were committed in a manner that showed utter contempt for the lives of their victims. The victims were made to suffer.” The Crown also argued that the applicants’ relative youth and lack of criminal records were largely irrelevant, and that the mandatory minimum sentence was not grossly disproportionate in their circumstances.

Brown addressed section 12 of the Charter, which states that everyone has the right not to be subjected to cruel and unusual punishment or treatment. She said the current laws allow no consideration of why someone might commit two murders and do not recognize rehabilitation that may occur before 25 years. She wrote: “A sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of applying for parole for 25 years for all offenders, regardless of the circumstances, is grossly disproportionate and therefore violates section 12 of the Charter.”

The Crown has said it will challenge the decision under section 1 of the Charter, which guarantees the rights and freedoms set out in it subject only to reasonable limits prescribed by law. Those arguments will be heard in the new year, and the judge is expected to rule on the three men’s sentences Feb. 22.

Read the original source · Surrey Now-Leader

GOOD THINGS HAPPEN HERE

Download Yo! Vancouver

Scan with your phone camera to discover more local favourites.

Scan to download Yo! Vancouver

Or choose your app store

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play