METRO VANCOUVER NEWS
Chase De Balinhard inquest ends with 11 recommendations to prevent similar deaths
After two weeks of emotional testimony, a coroner’s jury issued 11 non-binding recommendations on crisis information, family contact, police resources, realistic-looking pellet guns and supports for autistic and neurodivergent children. The inquest did not assign blame.

This story discusses suicide, mental health crises and the death of a child. Support information appears at the end. For nearly 21 months, Crystal and Rick De Balinhard have sought answers about the final moments of their only son’s life. After two weeks of testimony that brought police officers, health professionals, educators and the family to tears, a five-member jury unanimously classified 15-year-old Chase De Balinhard’s death as a homicide. Presiding coroner John Knox stressed that the term is a neutral designation and does not imply fault or blame. The jury issued 11 recommendations aimed at reducing the risk of similar deaths. They address access to critical mental health information, police efforts to contact families during crises, services for autistic and neurodivergent children, specialized police mental health teams and realistic-looking pellet guns. Despite extensive evidence about training, the jury did not specifically recommend additional autism-awareness or de-escalation training for officers.
Chase was shot and killed by police in Surrey on Feb. 9, 2025, after calling 911 himself to report that he had a revolver and was experiencing suicidal thoughts. The weapon was later identified as a realistic-looking, CO2-powered pellet gun. A separate investigation by the IIO found the officers’ use of lethal force legally justified and found no reasonable grounds to believe an officer had committed a criminal offence. The coroner’s inquest was a separate process to establish the circumstances of Chase’s death and consider ways to prevent similar deaths. Its recommendations were not directed at one person or organization; they concern government ministries, police agencies, health authorities, the education system and the province’s independent police watchdog. They are not legally binding. The chief coroner will forward them to the responsible agencies, which can publicly explain what they intend to do or why they may not act. Responses are posted on the B.C. Coroners Service website, but the process currently relies on agencies to report their own progress. Ministry spokesperson Amber Schinkel told CTV News the service depends on agencies to provide responses and that organizations face significant reputational risk if they claim to have made changes that were not implemented. She also said an internal process to strengthen follow-up is being developed, starting in 2027. It is not clear whether that process will include independent verification. Knox is expected to add comments to the published verdict.
On the afternoon of Feb. 9, Chase called 911 from a wooded area near Clayton Heights Secondary School. He spoke with Surrey Police Service call-taker Michael Peteers for about 19 minutes. The recording, played publicly at the inquest, captured Chase’s emotional state. Although he expressed suicidal thoughts, he was calm and polite through much of the call, apologizing when he struggled to answer questions. Asked for his home address, he said, “I’m sorry. I’m autistic.” He also described feeling isolated from peers: “Honestly, I don’t have any friends anymore. They just ignore me now.” The jury heard that Chase had been diagnosed with autism, ADHD, anxiety and other mental health challenges. His mother described a funny, kind-hearted boy who loved holidays, practical jokes, costumes, surprising neighbours and helping others. She also said he struggled with complicated instructions, social interactions and regulating his emotions when overwhelmed. Loud voices, crowded places and aggressive tones could intensify his distress. He had been taught to walk away, take deep breaths, listen to music or seek comfort from familiar people and activities.
Chase’s treating psychiatrist, Dr. Patricia Frew, testified that he had a history of chronic suicidal thoughts but that she had not identified an active plan requiring hospitalization at their last appointment about a month before his death. She cautioned that she could not determine his state of mind on the day he died. His mother also told jurors he was experiencing considerable physical discomfort while recovering from surgery. During the 911 call, Chase said he was carrying what he described as a revolver and that he did not trust police. When Peteers asked whether that distrust included wanting to harm officers, Chase answered, “Both.” Peteers said he took the comments seriously and entered the information into the dispatch system. He had general emergency call-taking instruction but no dedicated training on how autistic callers may interpret complicated questions, unfamiliar terms or ambiguous language. He testified that he tried to stay calm and avoid escalating Chase’s distress, and would welcome more practical autism-specific training.
Officers were told during the emergency that Chase was autistic and had ADHD. Some information came through Car 67, a specialized response team pairing a police officer with a psychiatric nurse. Fraser Health registered psychiatric nurse Ashley Strasdin searched Chase’s available medical records while responding with Surrey Police Const. Mark Peterse, an experienced crisis negotiator. She found a psychiatric assessment listing diagnoses and medication and shared relevant information with officers, but acknowledged she did not provide individualized communication strategies. “I don’t know how to communicate with him. I’ve never interacted with him before,” she testified. The inquest repeatedly distinguished knowing that a teenager is autistic from knowing how that individual responds to fear, what may trigger sensory overload or what could help build trust. Chase’s family and some professionals who had worked with him knew those details, and much of the information was documented, but it was not readily available to responders.
Chase had a safety plan developed in 2023. It included listening to music and looking at pictures of his cat, Ava, as well as contact information for people who could support him. Strasdin did not find the document while searching his extensive medical history. She was gathering information during a fast-moving emergency while monitoring the scene. The jury heard that the challenge was not necessarily a lack of information, but the difficulty of quickly finding the most useful details. The first two recommendations ask the Ministry of Health, Fraser Health and the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General to consider improving access to concise, current crisis information provided voluntarily. That could include letting families share details in advance for authorized responders to access during an emergency. Crystal had raised a voluntary registry in her testimony, saying it could help first responders understand a vulnerable person’s individual needs before a crisis escalates. The jury also recommended reviewing whether youth safety plans should include information about low-velocity, imitation or conventional firearms known to be stored in their homes. The recommendations do not require a registry or mandate information-sharing procedures, and recognize that privacy issues must be addressed before sensitive medical information is made available to responders. Strasdin said plans must be kept current because a strategy that works for a child at one age may not work years later.
The fourth recommendation addresses barriers to health professionals accessing records across health authority boundaries. Strasdin said Car 67 nurses could generally access Fraser Health records but not detailed clinical information held by other regional health authorities. Asked whether broader access would help mental health responders, she said, “Absolutely.” The jury recommended that the Ministry of Health review whether those barriers could be reduced so critical information is available when needed. The inquest did not establish that access to Chase’s safety plan would have changed the outcome, but raised questions about whether existing information could be put to better use.
Strasdin testified that she tried to call Crystal using a number in Chase’s medical records. She hoped his mother could offer familiar words, interests or communication strategies to help officers connect with him. “Parents, whoever’s taking care of the individual, knows them the best,” she told jurors. She could not reach Crystal and did not remember whether the calls went to voicemail. The family disputes receiving the calls and showed CTV News phone records they say contain no incoming call during the emergency. The inquest did not resolve the discrepancy. Jurors also heard that text messaging was available. An officer considered going to the De Balinhards’ home for information but testified the escalating situation required him elsewhere. The eighth recommendation asks Surrey Police Service to review what should happen when an initial attempt to reach family fails, including whether further attempts should be governed by policy or left to officer discretion, and the order in which contact methods are tried. Strasdin cautioned that contacting relatives can sometimes put a vulnerable person at greater risk, depending on circumstances and relationships. The jury recommended a review, not an automatic requirement to contact family in every mental health emergency. The evidence did not establish that reaching Chase’s parents would have prevented the shooting. For the family, however, the lost opportunity to share information about their son remains significant.
Peterse testified that he first saw Chase sitting near a fence with what appeared to be a revolver beside him. The officer introduced himself by his first name and waved, hoping to seem approachable. Chase then stood, picked up the apparent firearm, swore and walked away. Peterse said he repeatedly tried to reassure him as officers followed through nearby trails, parkland and residential areas: “I was yelling, Chase, you’re safe. We’re not here to hurt you. We’re here to help.” Chase did not respond. Under questioning from the family’s lawyer, J.A. Pankiw-Petty, Peterse acknowledged that some techniques might have unintended effects on someone experiencing autistic sensory overload. He said he sometimes called to Chase from a considerable distance and had to raise his voice to be heard. Asked whether the shouting may have contributed to Chase becoming overwhelmed, he said, “I hope I didn’t, but you know, it’s not what my intent was.” He stressed that officers believed they were dealing with a suicidal teenager carrying a real firearm. “Unfortunately, it’s still a gun call,” he testified. The jury heard that officers tried to contain Chase as he moved through public areas, repeatedly pointing what appeared to be a handgun at police and at times at his own head. Surveillance video captured part of the encounter, including officers ordering him to drop the weapon.
RCMP Const. Paul Sandhu testified that Chase pointed the apparent firearm at him during one encounter, but he did not fire because civilians were behind the teenager. Delta Police Cpl. Christopher Cottrill, a police dog handler, described another encounter in which he believed the firearm was pointed directly at him. “I remember the exact thought that went through my mind. It was, ‘Well, I guess I’m not going home today,’” he testified. Cottrill decided not to release his dog because he feared a bite might cause Chase to involuntarily pull the trigger. Peterse considered using a less-lethal launcher but faced challenges involving distance, visibility and the risk of provoking someone believed to have a loaded handgun. Two RCMP officers ultimately fired after Chase pointed the apparent firearm at police. One bullet struck his chest. The IIO later concluded officers had reasonable grounds to fear death or grievous bodily harm and that lethal force was legally justified. The inquest examined whether communication, training and emergency resources could help prevent similar deaths, not whether officers should be found criminally or civilly responsible.
The third recommendation calls for a review of the capacity and equipment available to specialized police mental health teams such as Car 67 and Car 99. The inquest heard that only one Car 67 unit was available at a time to serve all of Surrey. Strasdin said more psychiatric nurses would help: “Absolutely. We could use one in every single district in Surrey.” Travel times, limited geographic coverage and equipment or connectivity problems could also affect how quickly specialized responders joined emergencies. The jury recommended reviewing staffing, hours, equipment and coverage against community needs. A separate recommendation asks Surrey Police to examine whether its helicopter and drone resources are sufficient. The Air One police helicopter was unavailable on weekends; Chase was shot on a Sunday. Sandhu suggested aerial resources might have helped officers track Chase as he moved through public areas. The jury recommended reviewing whether better access could improve responses, but did not conclude that a helicopter, drone or more mental health staff would have prevented his death.
Another major issue was the weapon Chase carried. The Crosman .22-calibre CO2-powered pellet revolver closely resembled a conventional handgun. Civilians and officers believed it was a real revolver, and an officer who later examined it identified its distinguishing CO2 features only on closer inspection. Two Canadian Firearms Program representatives said the device fell into a category exempt from several federal firearms rules. Senior firearms technician Peter Pau testified that no federal firearms licence or registration was required to acquire or possess this particular air gun. It was not subject to the specific federal storage requirements that apply to many conventional firearms, and there was no federal requirement for an orange tip or another conspicuous marking to distinguish it from a real handgun. Pau compared its appearance to a large Smith & Wesson revolver. The fifth recommendation asks federal and provincial governments to review whether realistic-looking pellet guns should have clear, durable and conspicuous visual differences from conventional firearms. It also raises questions about manufacturing and import rules, including whether markings should resist removal or alteration.
B.C.’s Firearm Violence Prevention Act was passed in 2021, but key provisions affecting pellet guns did not take effect until Oct. 1, 2026, more than 19 months after Chase’s death. The law generally prohibits selling low-velocity and imitation firearms to minors, subject to exceptions, and sets rules for how youth carry, transport and store them. These include restrictions on loaded low-velocity firearms and requirements for locked, opaque containers in certain circumstances. The province also prohibits unsafe use or storage that creates a risk to public safety. However, the law does not universally require adults to lock every low-velocity pellet gun inside their homes, and it does not establish the federal visual-marking rules the jury wants governments to consider. Crystal testified that Rick inherited the revolver from his father, who had served with the RCMP. She said it was normally kept in a locked drawer in Rick’s office, with the key stored separately in a combination-lock safe. Rick previously told CTV News the drawer may have been left unlocked after he retrieved something. Chase gave a different account during his 911 call, saying he knew which key opened the drawer. The evidence did not conclusively establish how he accessed the revolver. Because it was inherited rather than bought by Chase, restrictions on sales to minors would not necessarily address how this particular device came into the family home. The jury specifically acknowledged the new B.C. legislation and asked whether further federal or provincial measures are needed.
The inquest also considered the support Chase received at school and throughout his life. His mother described years of medical appointments, autism assessments, counselling and efforts to secure educational support. Chase was diagnosed with autism in 2018, after his family had spent years trying to understand his developmental needs. Crystal said he struggled with reading, writing, social communication and processing instructions. Although he was 15, his parents said his developmental functioning was younger in some areas. She testified that he received substantial educational assistance in elementary school, but that support diminished in high school. By Grade 10, he was receiving very little help despite continuing academic and emotional challenges. School personnel described changes to his support and difficulties maintaining continuity. The sixth recommendation asks the Ministry of Education and Child Care and the Ministry of Children and Family Development to review how services for autistic and other neurodivergent students are delivered and monitored. It asks whether services identified as important for a student are actually being provided, and calls for better family communication when support changes. The recommendation goes beyond funding debates to ask how the system ensures a child receives the support identified as necessary. Evidence did not establish that changes to Chase’s school support caused his death, but raised wider concerns about continuity, oversight and communication among schools, families and government agencies.
The final recommendation asks the Ministry of Children and Family Development, Fraser Health and Surrey School District to review whether families of autistic and neurodivergent children have clear information about autism and mental health supports. Crystal described years of seeking help through different agencies and professionals, sometimes struggling to identify services or how to access them. The jury recognized the challenge of navigating several organizations and called for better coordination and clearer information, not a new funding model. The tenth recommendation asks Surrey Police Service and Surrey School District to explore ways to improve relationships and trust between police and young people. Jurors heard limited general evidence about the potential role of school liaison officer programs in building positive relationships. The recommendation does not call for establishing or reinstating a particular school policing program; it encourages the organizations to explore how trust can be developed before an emergency. This connects to a recurring question: how responders can communicate with someone who may already be frightened, overwhelmed or distrustful.
Despite the repeated focus on autism and communication, the jury did not recommend additional autism-specific police training requirements. Crystal told the jury the family’s advocacy was not about blaming officers: “We know they didn’t go up there to hurt our son. It’s never been us against them. It’s just about training.” Several witnesses acknowledged limits in their autism-specific training. Peterse described his training as comparatively limited despite years of crisis-negotiation experience. Other officers said more information about neurodivergence could be useful, while emphasizing that they believed they faced an armed person who posed a danger to police and the public. The IIO’s December 2025 report identified gaps in autism-specific training among interviewed officers and found no evidence the officer who fired the fatal shot had received such instruction. The inquest also heard about training already underway. Surrey Police Insp. Kelly Wong said the department had offered introductory autism education to newly hired experienced officers since 2021. Peterse attended a 30-minute introductory session in October that year. Surrey Police later expanded its program through a partnership with the Canucks Autism Network. New one-hour introductory sessions began in June 2025, alongside online courses and a full-day workshop using realistic scenarios, including responding to an autistic student at school and assisting an autistic person whose behaviour has been misunderstood in public. At the time of Wong’s testimony, 12 officers had completed the full-day workshop. It was not mandatory for every serving officer, and no deadline was given for training the entire service. Other B.C. police agencies have also introduced or expanded autism-specific training. In 2025, the province updated mandatory Crisis Intervention and De-escalation training to include autism and neurodivergence; the rollout is expected to continue through November 2028. Autism organizations were invited into discussions following CTV News’s Lost in Translation Investigation. The initiatives show new training is underway, although the jury made no recommendation for additional requirements. After the verdict, Crystal said she had hoped for more training, but was encouraged by Surrey Police Service’s progress and tools. She hoped her son’s death had already prompted wider discussion about how first responders interact with neurodivergent people. “Chase’s death, something good is coming from it,” she said.
The jury heard emotional testimony from Chase’s family, officers and first responders. Peterse described rushing to Chase after hearing gunshots, performing CPR and trying to comfort him as responders attempted to save him. He stroked Chase’s hair and reassured him that he was safe and loved. “I’m so sorry. I wish I could have done more for Chase. I tried everything I could,” he testified. His account brought family members to tears and prompted a brief pause in proceedings. Through their lawyer, J.A. Pankiw-Petty, Chase’s parents thanked Peterse for the compassion he showed their son. Strasdin said she took over medical assistance after the shooting and stayed with Chase in his final moments. “I was at Chase’s head, and I closed his eyes, and I just told him he was free, and that, you know, he’s cared for, and he’s loved,” she testified. She recalled Crystal’s anguish at the scene: “Her scream is something that I will never forget.” Strasdin rejected suggestions that responders were indifferent to Chase’s suffering and said, “He was cared for to the very last second.” The accounts reflected the deep impact on the family, responders and wider community. The recommendations do not assign blame; they consider whether changes to existing systems could reduce the risk of similar tragedies.
The inquest also examined what happens after a death involving police. Crystal described arriving near the scene after discovering Chase’s phone appeared to be in the area where police were responding, learning that he had been shot and killed, and waiting for answers while the IIO investigation remained active. The jury heard that the IIO assigned an affected-person liaison to communicate with and support the family, but limits on releasing information during an active investigation restricted what could be shared. The seventh recommendation asks the IIO to review its communication with affected families, including how often it provides updates and how clearly it explains what can and cannot be released. It also suggests considering whether the liaison process offers services comparable to or better than police-based victim services. The recommendation recognizes the need to protect investigations while improving communication with grieving families.
Chase’s family says he wanted to make people happy and leave the world better than he found it. He loved holidays, superheroes, costumes and making people laugh, and was passionate about giving back. As a child, he and friends sold Freezies to raise money for cancer research. After his death, the same friends organized a fundraiser in his memory, raising more than $10,000 for the Terry Fox Foundation. Those memories remain important to Crystal and Rick as part of who their son was beyond the circumstances of his death. After Friday’s verdict, Crystal said: “Chase did. He wanted to change the world. He wanted the world to be a better place, and the world is a better place because of Chase.” She said his death had sparked conversations already leading to change. Nothing can bring Chase home, she said, but the family hopes those conversations continue after the inquest.
If you or someone you know is struggling with mental health or thoughts of suicide, confidential support is available. Call or text 988, Canada’s Suicide Crisis Helpline, available 24 hours a day, seven days a week. B.C.’s suicide crisis line: 1-800-SUICIDE (1-800-784-2433). B.C.’s Mental Health Support Line: 310-6789, with no area code required. Kids Help Phone: young people can call 1-800-668-6868 or text CONNECT to 686868. If someone is in immediate danger, call 911. You do not have to be in an immediate crisis to ask for help.